Detailed Answer
When an executor refuses to cooperate in paying a cash bequest, Alabama law gives beneficiaries several tools to enforce the will and protect estate assets. The general path is: document the bequest and your status as a beneficiary; formally demand payment and an accounting from the executor; and, if the executor still refuses, ask the probate court to compel an accounting, order distribution, or remove and surcharge the executor for breach of fiduciary duty. Alabama’s probate rules and the statutes governing probate and decedents’ estates are found in Title 43 of the Alabama Code (Probate and Decedents’ Estates): https://www.legislature.state.al.us/aliswww/ISD/ALCode.aspx?title=43.
Below are concrete, practical steps you can take, with the typical legal actions the probate court can order in Alabama when an executor won’t cooperate.
-
Gather documents and confirm your entitlement.
Locate the will, death certificate, any letters from the executor or probate court filings, bank statements showing the bequest hasn’t been paid, and any communications showing the executor’s refusal. Make copies and keep a careful timeline of events. Confirm that the will names you as the beneficiary of a cash bequest and that the will has been admitted to probate (or find out whether the executor has opened the estate). These items are what the probate court will want to see.
-
Request a written accounting and demand payment.
Send a written demand to the executor (registered mail or other verifiable delivery) asking for (a) confirmation that the estate is in probate, (b) a complete accounting of assets and liabilities, and (c) payment of your specific cash bequest. Alabama executors are fiduciaries; they must administer the estate in good faith and report to the court and beneficiaries. If the executor is unfamiliar with duties, this request often triggers compliance.
-
Check the probate court file and deadlines.
Contact the probate court where the decedent lived to confirm whether the will has been filed and to obtain the estate case number and any filed inventories or accountings. The probate clerk can tell you what has been filed and how to request a hearing. Many probate matters follow local procedures, so the court clerk or the court’s website is a useful resource (Alabama Judicial System information: https://judicial.alabama.gov).
-
File a petition in probate court to compel an accounting or distribution.
If the executor fails to respond, beneficiaries can petition the probate court for relief. Typical petitions include:
- Petition for an accounting or a copy of the executor’s inventory and report.
- Motion to compel distribution of specific legacies when funds are available.
- Petition to remove the executor for cause (misconduct, refusal to perform duties, conflict of interest, or gross mismanagement).
The probate court has authority to order an accounting, require the executor to produce records, and direct distribution. If the executor improperly withholds estate property or money, the court can enter an order requiring payment and can impose penalties or surcharge the executor for losses caused by misconduct. See Title 43 (Probate and Decedents’ Estates) for the statutory framework: Alabama Code, Title 43.
-
Ask the court to remove or surcharge the executor when appropriate.
Removal: If the executor is breaching duties, acting in bad faith, wasting estate assets, or refusing to act, you can ask the court to remove the executor and appoint a successor representative. Surcharge: If the executor’s misconduct caused financial loss, the court can order the executor to reimburse the estate (and thus preserve the bequest).
-
Consider small-estate alternatives.
If the estate’s assets are small, Alabama may permit summary procedures (small estate affidavit or simplified probate) that allow distribution with less court formality. These procedures vary by dollar thresholds and by whether the asset is real property or personal property. Check the probate clerk or Title 43 guidance for whether a simplified route is available in your case.
-
Preserve evidence and avoid informal agreements without court approval.
Do not accept informal promises from an executor who already refused to cooperate. Verbal promises are hard to enforce. If you reach a private agreement, get it in writing and, when possible, approved by the probate court so it becomes an enforceable order.
-
Hire an attorney if necessary.
When the executor resists court orders, or if the estate is complex, retaining a probate attorney is often the quickest way to secure distribution. An attorney can prepare petitions, represent you at hearings, and pursue remedies like surcharge, removal, or an order directing payment. If cost is a concern, ask prospective attorneys about limited-scope representation or contingency arrangements where appropriate.
What the probate court can order
- Compel the executor to file inventories and accountings and to disclose estate records.
- Order payment of specific bequests if estate funds are available.
- Remove or replace an executor who breaches fiduciary duties.
- Surcharge the executor for losses caused by mismanagement or wrongful withholding of estate assets.
Timing and practical points
Act promptly. Beneficiaries often have to move quickly to protect rights and to keep assets from being dissipated. Even if there are statutory time limits for contests or other claims, courts expect beneficiaries to pursue relief without undue delay. The probate clerk can tell you what filings exist and local practice about hearings and notices.
Key legal resources: Alabama Code, Title 43 (Probate and Decedents’ Estates), available from the Alabama Legislature: https://www.legislature.state.al.us/aliswww/ISD/ALCode.aspx?title=43. Local probate court procedures and filing requirements are available from your county probate court; general information about Alabama courts is available at the Alabama Judicial System: https://judicial.alabama.gov.
Sample demand language (short):
“I am a named beneficiary under the Last Will of [Decedent]. Per the will admitted to probate in [County] Probate Court, I am entitled to a cash bequest of $[amount]. Please provide (1) a written accounting of estate assets and liabilities, (2) confirmation of available funds to satisfy the bequest, and (3) payment of the bequest within 14 days of this letter. If you do not provide the accounting and payment, I will petition the Probate Court to compel an accounting and seek enforcement of the bequest.”
Use that letter as a starting point. Have a lawyer tailor timing and content to your facts if the matter escalates.
When to involve other remedies
If the executor refuses to act and the probate court cannot immediately enforce compliance, beneficiaries can pursue civil claims for conversion or breach of fiduciary duty in a county civil court in addition to probate remedies. Because overlapping remedies can be complex, speak with a probate attorney before filing parallel suits.
Disclaimer: This article explains general steps under Alabama probate law for informational purposes only. It is not legal advice, and it does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about your particular situation, consult a licensed Alabama probate attorney.
Helpful Hints
- Always make requests in writing and keep copies and delivery receipts.
- Get the probate case number and court file to review filings and deadlines.
- Keep a timeline of all communications with the executor and estate professionals.
- Ask the probate clerk about small-estate procedures if the estate is modest in value.
- Consider a limited initial consultation with a probate lawyer to learn your options before filing paperwork.
- If you suspect theft or fraud, preserve evidence and notify the court promptly; criminal referrals are possible in serious cases.
- Be prepared to show proof of your identity and your status as a beneficiary (copy of the will or court filings).
- If family tensions are high, mediation through the court or a neutral mediator can sometimes speed resolution without protracted litigation.