What options do heirs have when an estate administrator becomes unresponsive or refuses to distribute assets? (FL) | Florida Probate | FastCounsel
Get Matched
FL Florida Probate

What options do heirs have when an estate administrator becomes unresponsive or refuses to distribute assets? (FL)

August 7, 2025 7 min read

Detailed answer — What heirs can do when a Florida estate administrator (personal representative) is unresponsive or refuses to distribute assets

When an estate administrator (called a personal representative in Florida) stops communicating, delays distribution, or refuses to distribute assets, heirs have clear legal options under Florida law. The steps below explain what heirs can reasonably expect, how to preserve rights, and the common court remedies available. This is a general guide only — it does not replace legal advice.

1. Quick overview: the administrator’s duties

Under Florida law, the personal representative has a fiduciary duty to manage the estate, pay valid debts and expenses, account for estate assets, and distribute assets to beneficiaries according to the will or Florida intestacy law. The Florida probate statutes that govern these duties are in Chapter 733 of the Florida Statutes. For an overview of the statutory framework see the Florida Statutes, Chapter 733 (Decedents’ estates): https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0700-0799/0733/0733ContentsIndex.html.

2. First steps heirs should take (practical, low-cost actions)

  • Check the probate case file: Visit or contact the county clerk where the estate was opened and ask for the probate file (many clerks have online portals). The file shows what the personal representative has filed, inventories, accountings, and any petitions.
  • Send a written demand: Draft a clear, dated, written request for an accounting and distribution. Send it by certified mail (keep receipt) or another method that creates proof of delivery. Include a reasonable deadline (e.g., 14–30 days).
  • Request an informal accounting: Ask the administrator for an itemized accounting of assets, receipts, expenses, creditor payments, and distributions. Florida beneficiaries are entitled to examine the probate records and often to receive an accounting.
  • Document communications: Keep copies of all emails, letters, texts, and notes about phone calls. This record is important if you need to go to court.
  • Talk to other interested parties: Coordinate with co-beneficiaries or creditors — they may be willing to act together (cost-sharing and stronger position).

3. Common legal remedies in Florida

If informal requests fail, heirs can ask the probate court to intervene. Common petitions and remedies include:

  • Petition for an accounting: Ask the court to order the personal representative to file a formal accounting. An accounting shows assets on hand, transactions, and proposed distributions. If the PR fails to account, the court can compel one.
  • Motion to compel distribution: If the estate administration is essentially complete (claims resolved, taxes paid, expenses covered), beneficiaries can petition the court to compel distribution of the remaining assets.
  • Petition for removal: If the personal representative has breached duties (misconduct, neglect, incompetence, refusal to act, conflict of interest, misappropriation), heirs can petition to remove and replace the PR. The court will review evidence and may appoint a successor.
  • Surcharge or claim for breach of fiduciary duty: If assets were misapplied, lost, or wasted because of the PR’s actions, heirs can ask the court to surcharge (financially charge) the PR for losses and recover funds.
  • Petition to appoint a special or successor administrator: For urgent matters (asset at risk or PR incapacitated), the court can appoint a temporary special administrator or replace the PR to protect estate property.
  • Contempt or sanctions: If the PR disobeys a court order (for example, refuses to turn over assets after the court orders distribution), the court may hold the PR in contempt and impose sanctions, including fines or jail in extreme cases.
  • Civil suit outside probate: In some cases (fraud, conversion, theft), beneficiaries may bring separate civil lawsuits against the PR or third parties to recover assets.

Many of these remedies are handled within the probate case or by filing related petitions in the probate court. For procedural rules and how summary distributions may work, Florida recognizes summary administration in certain low-value or short-death-period cases—see Florida Statutes Chapter 735 (summary administration): https://www.leg.state.fl.us/statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Display_Statute&URL=0700-0799/0735/Sections/0735.201.html.

4. Evidence you will need

  • Copies of the will and the probate case number.
  • All communications with the personal representative and any formal demands sent.
  • Proof of your status as an heir or beneficiary (e.g., will, family tree, birth certificates if intestate succession applies).
  • Any financial records you possess (bank statements, knowledge of assets, deeds, titles).
  • Probate court filings you can obtain from the county clerk.

5. Timing and likely costs

Procedural timing varies by county and how contested the matter becomes. Simple petitions (like requesting an accounting) can be handled in weeks to months. Contested removal or complex surcharge claims can take many months and increase legal costs. Expect court filing fees and attorney fees if you hire counsel. In many instances the court may award fees against the estate if a removal or breach is proven, but that is fact-dependent.

6. When a lawyer makes sense

  • When the PR refuses to provide any accounting or ignores formal demands.
  • When you suspect assets were taken, hidden, or misused.
  • When a court hearing (removal, surcharge, contempt) is likely and you need to present evidence and legal argument.
  • When co-heirs disagree or multiple estates/creditor claims complicate distribution.

A probate attorney can prepare petitions, gather evidence, and represent you at hearings. If cost is a concern, ask about limited-scope representation or an initial consult to evaluate strength of your claim.

7. Practical examples (hypothetical)

Example 1: The PR fails to respond to repeated requests and has not filed a final accounting. Heirs file a petition for an accounting and a motion to set a hearing date. The court orders the PR to file a full accounting within 30 days or appear. The PR complies or is replaced.

Example 2: A PR sells estate property and keeps proceeds without court approval. Heirs file a petition for surcharge and removal. The court investigates, orders an accounting, and may order the PR to repay funds or be surcharged for losses.

8. How to start — a practical checklist

  1. Obtain the probate case number and file from the county clerk.
  2. Send a written demand for an accounting and distribution; keep proof of delivery.
  3. Coordinate with other beneficiaries to decide next steps.
  4. If no response within the deadline, consult a probate attorney about filing a petition in probate court (accounting, motion to compel, or petition for removal).
  5. Preserve evidence and financial records; avoid confrontational actions that could complicate court proceedings.

Helpful links

Helpful Hints

  • Always put requests in writing and keep copies. Courts prefer documented attempts at resolution before contested litigation.
  • Check the probate docket online or at the clerk’s office before filing — many issues are already recorded there.
  • Work with other beneficiaries to share costs and present a united front — multiple petitioners can be persuasive to a court.
  • Don’t assume delay means malfeasance. Some delays are caused by unresolved creditor claims, missing assets, or tax issues. Get an accounting before assuming the worst.
  • If you suspect theft or criminal conduct, you can report to law enforcement, but civil remedies in probate are usually the primary route for recovery of estate property.
  • Consider mediation or settlement if the PR is responsive to negotiation — it can save time and fees.

Disclaimer: This information is for educational purposes only and is not legal advice. It does not create an attorney-client relationship. For advice about a specific situation in Florida, consult a licensed Florida probate attorney.

The information on this site is for general informational purposes only, may be outdated, and is not legal advice; do not rely on it without consulting your own attorney.