Detailed answer: How a co-owner can force a sale or division of inherited property in Montana when other owners won’t respond
This is a plain-language explanation of the typical path to a partition action in Montana when you inherit real property with other owners and some co-owners are not responding. This is educational information only and is not legal advice. Consult a licensed attorney in Montana to protect your rights and meet court deadlines.
What a partition action is
A partition action is a lawsuit asking the Montana district court to divide jointly owned real property among co-owners (a partition in kind) or to order a sale of the property and divide the proceeds (a partition by sale). Anyone with an ownership interest—an heir, devisee, or current title owner—can usually file.
Who should bring the case
The plaintiff is typically a co-owner who wants the property divided or sold. If the deceased owner’s estate is still in probate, the estate’s personal representative may need to bring or join the action until title transfers to heirs. If title already shows the heirs or co-owners, any owner on title can file.
Basic steps to file and pursue a partition action in Montana
-
Gather documents and facts.
Collect the deed(s), death certificate, will or probate documents (if any), mortgage and lien information, tax statements, and any written communications among owners. Get a property description or recent survey if available.
-
Confirm ownership type and who must be joined.
Most inherited property will be held as tenants in common among heirs. The court generally requires that all persons with an ownership interest be joined as defendants. If someone is a minor or legally incapacitated, special procedures apply and you must notify the court so a guardian or guardian ad litem can be appointed.
-
Try to resolve the dispute out of court first.
Send a written demand to buy your share or to sell and divide proceeds. Explain a deadline for response. Offer mediation or a buyout. Courts often require or favor settlement efforts before a sale.
-
File the partition complaint in district court.
File in the Montana district court for the county where the property lies. Your complaint should describe the property, list all owners and their addresses (to the extent you know them), and state the relief you request (partition in kind, sale, appointment of commissioners, accounting for rents and mortgages, and court costs).
-
Serve all defendants (co-owners).
Proper service of process is crucial. If a co-owner won’t respond but you can locate them, serve them personally or by certified mail as the rules require. If you cannot locate a co-owner, Montana courts allow substituted service or service by publication when permitted by the rules. The court may require you to show reasonable efforts to locate the missing owner before allowing publication.
-
If a co-owner does not answer, seek default or proceed without them.
If a defendant is properly served and does not answer within the time required by court rules, you can ask the court to enter a default. The court can then proceed to resolve the partition with the absent owner’s interest treated according to court order. Courts still must protect due process—missing owners often must be given notice by publication and an opportunity to come forward within a set time.
-
Court fact-finding and possible commissioners.
A judge may order a physical partition if practical. If a fair physical division is not practical, the court will order a sale and appoint a commissioner or referee to manage appraisal and sale. The court will account for mortgages, liens, taxes, and expenses before dividing net proceeds among owners according to their interests.
-
Final decree and distribution of proceeds.
The court issues a final decree describing the partition or sale and directing distribution of proceeds after payment of debts, costs, and commissions. Anyone dissatisfied may appeal within the time limits set by Montana law.
How to handle unresponsive owners — practical tools Montana courts use
- Service by publication when a defendant’s address is unknown (after reasonable search).
- Substituted or constructive service where permitted by court rules.
- Appointment of guardians or guardians ad litem for minors or incapacitated owners.
- Default judgments if a properly served owner fails to answer.
- Appointment of commissioners to sell property if partition in kind is impractical.
Common complications and how they change the process
-
Property is still in probate.
If the decedent’s estate is open, you may need the personal representative to bring the partition action or for the court to order transfer of title to heirs before a partition can finalize.
-
Mismatched records.
Deeds, tax records, and probate records may list different names. A title search and probate documents help identify current owners who must be joined.
-
Mortgages, liens, or taxes owed.
Liens and mortgages generally survive a partition and must be paid from sale proceeds or otherwise addressed in the decree.
-
Disagreement on valuation.
The court may order appraisals or allow the parties to present evidence of value. Commissioners typically follow court instructions on valuation and sale methods.
Where to find Montana forms and statutes
Montana’s court information and self-help resources are at the Judicial Branch site: https://courts.mt.gov/. Use the Montana Code Annotated site to search state statutes and rules (search terms: “partition,” “real property,” “service by publication”): https://leg.mt.gov/bills/mca/. For local procedural rules and filing instructions, check the district court clerk in the county where the property is located via the Montana courts site.
Practical timeline and costs to expect
- Initial negotiations and document gathering: days to weeks.
- Filing and service: usually a few weeks depending on locating owners.
- If owners are unresponsive and service by publication is needed: allow months for publication timelines and waiting periods.
- Discovery, appraisal, and sale can stretch the case several months to a year or more.
- Costs: court filing fees, service costs, title searches, appraisals, commissions, attorney fees if you hire counsel. Courts may award costs and attorney fees in certain circumstances, but you should not rely on that outcome.
When to get a Montana attorney
Hire a Montana lawyer if any of these apply: co-owners are unresponsive or hostile; probate is unresolved; minors or incapacitated persons are involved; the title is unclear; significant mortgages or liens exist; you want to pursue or defend a default or appeal. A lawyer will handle pleadings, service, discovery, and court hearings and can advise on settlement options like buyouts.
Helpful hints
- Document every attempt to contact co-owners (letters, certified mail receipts, emails, phone logs). Courts look for evidence of reasonable efforts before allowing alternative service methods.
- Request a title search early to identify all recorded interests and potential parties to the suit.
- Consider a written buyout offer or mediation before filing; it can save time and money.
- If service by publication is necessary, start early. Publication requires specific affidavits and proof of attempts to locate the owner.
- Get a recent appraisal to support your requested relief and to guard against undervaluing the property in a forced sale.
- When possible, keep the property insured, pay property taxes, and maintain the property during the case to preserve value and avoid liens.
- Ask the court for an accounting of rents, profits, and expenses if the property produced income or if co-owners consumed value without sharing expenses.
- If the estate is open in probate, talk with the personal representative about coordination between probate and a partition action to prevent conflicting orders.
Important: This content is educational only and is not legal advice. For advice specific to your situation, consult a licensed Montana attorney.