Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This article explains general information about Tennessee law and common options. It is not legal advice. For advice about your exact case, consult a licensed Tennessee attorney.
Detailed Answer
Quick overview of the legal background under Tennessee law
When co-owners or divorcing spouses cannot agree about a house, Tennessee law gives courts two main frameworks that matter here:
- Division of marital property in a divorce under Tennessee’s equitable distribution rules (see Tenn. Code Ann. § 36-4-121).
- Court-ordered partition of real estate when co-owners disagree (see Tennessee’s partition statutes, generally found in Title 29).
Under these laws, a court may order sale of the property when it is practical and fair. But the decision to sell does not eliminate your options to protect your financial interest or to ask the court to set buyout terms instead of an immediate sale.
Statutes: Tenn. Code Ann. § 36-4-121 (equitable distribution): https://www.capitol.tn.gov/legislation/statutes/36-4-121.html. Partition provisions (Title 29): https://www.capitol.tn.gov/legislation/statutes/29-17-101.html.
If the other side only asks the court to sell the house (no buyout terms), here are your options
-
Object and ask the court to set buyout terms or hold a hearing.
If a petition or motion only asks for sale, file a written objection or response and ask the court to decide buyout terms (price, method, and timing). Ask for a hearing where you can present evidence about value, mortgage, contribution, and inability to refinance or pay cash. Courts can decide that a buyout (one party buying the other out) is the fair way to divide the property instead of a forced sale.
-
Request a formal appraisal or valuation.
Ask the court to order an appraisal or to appoint a neutral appraiser. A current, court-admissible appraisal gives you a realistic buyout price (equity less liens and sale costs). Provide the appraisal at the hearing and use it to support a buyout formula.
-
Propose buyout terms and show ability to pay (or refinancing plan).
Courts favor buyouts when one party can refinance or pay the other party’s share within a reasonable time. Prepare proof of financing pre-approval, a refinance timeline, or other proof of funds. Offer a buyout schedule if immediate cash is not possible.
-
Ask for temporary possession and financial orders.
Request temporary (interim) orders about who lives in the house, who pays mortgage/taxes/insurance, and who pays utilities until final resolution. These orders protect your credit and preserve equity while the court addresses buyout vs sale.
-
Offer or demand mediation or settlement negotiations.
Many courts require or encourage mediation in divorce and partition matters. Use mediation to negotiate buyout price, closing cost splits, and timelines. A negotiated buyout is usually faster and cheaper than a forced sale.
-
File a counterclaim for partition in kind or alternate relief.
If this is a non-divorce co-ownership (tenancy in common), you can file your own partition request asking the court to divide property in kind or to set more detailed sale/buyout terms. Tennessee partition law gives the court discretion about sale method and distribution of proceeds.
-
Prepare for sale but protect your interest in sale terms.
If the court orders a sale, ask the court to set sale mechanics: whether sale is by broker auction or private sale, how sale costs will be deducted, how liens will be paid, and how net proceeds will be split. You can also ask for a minimum sale price or require a court confirmation of any private sale to avoid low-ball offers.
Practical steps to take now (immediate checklist)
- Gather documents: deed, mortgage statements, tax bills, insurance, title report, and any appraisal or repair estimates.
- Keep paying the mortgage, taxes, and insurance if you can. Falling behind limits options and raises the chance of forced sale or foreclosure.
- Get a preliminary market valuation (licensed appraiser) so you understand equity and potential buyout numbers.
- If divorce is involved, file or respond to temporary motions asking for interim occupancy or payment orders.
- Consider mediation early — it often preserves more value and reduces legal fees.
- Talk to a Tennessee lawyer early. A lawyer can file the right motions, request appraisals, and present a buyout plan that courts accept.
How courts typically decide between buyout and sale
Court decisions balance fairness, practicality, and economic reality. Courts consider:
- Whether one party can reasonably refinance or pay cash for a buyout;
- Cost and delay of selling the property versus a buyout;
- Each party’s contribution to mortgage, maintenance, and improvements;
- Mortgage and lien obligations; and
- Whether sale is necessary to achieve a just division of property under Tenn. Code Ann. § 36-4-121 or partition statutes.
Costs, timing, and risks you should know
- Forced court sales can take many months and add attorney fees and sale expenses, reducing net proceeds.
- Buyouts shift closing costs and tax consequences; a refinance may carry higher interest or closing costs.
- If you fail to pay mortgage, the lender can foreclose regardless of the court dispute.
- Because court timelines vary, urgent financial relief (temporary orders) is often critical.
When to get a Tennessee attorney
If the other side moves for sale and you want a buyout, consult a Tennessee lawyer immediately. An attorney can file objections or temporary motions, obtain or challenge appraisals, and present a concrete buyout plan or negotiate settlement that the court will approve.
Helpful Hints
- Keep records of all payments you make on the house — mortgage, repairs, property tax, insurance — to support an equitable share claim.
- Get at least one independent appraisal early. A reliable valuation strengthens your buyout request.
- Start refinance conversations with lenders early if you hope to buy out the other party.
- Ask the court to require that any proposed private sale be confirmed by the judge to avoid a low offer being accepted without oversight.
- Use mediation: courts and judges often view mediated agreements more favorably than litigated, contested outcomes.
- If you receive a court notice, respond promptly to preserve your right to ask for buyout terms or a hearing.
- Remember taxes: capital gains and mortgage-interest rules affect net outcomes — consult a tax advisor as needed.
For the specific statutory language and procedures, review Tennessee’s statutes and consult an attorney who practices in Tennessee family law or real property/partition law. Relevant statutes include Tenn. Code Ann. § 36-4-121 (equitable distribution in divorce): https://www.capitol.tn.gov/legislation/statutes/36-4-121.html, and Tennessee’s partition provisions in Title 29: https://www.capitol.tn.gov/legislation/statutes/29-17-101.html.
If you want, provide a short summary of your situation (ownership status, divorce or not, who lives in the house, mortgage balance, and whether you can refinance). I can then explain common next steps you might expect in Tennessee and what documents to prepare for an attorney.